We're Not Your Average Insurance Agency

A new Definition of Insurance Agent

The Paul Wolf Insurance Agency promises to not only fulfill all of your insurance needs, we will also shop and compare rates to make sure you have the best coverage for the best price.

Get a Quote!

Your Name (required)

Your Email (required)

About Us

Who we are

The Paul Wolf Insurance Agency is not your average insurance agency. We do more than just compare rates; we work tirelessly to account for all of your insurance needs. We can help you plan for the future by considering all of your options for auto, home, commercial, and life insurance. Because we are a family-run business, our services include a personal touch that is unmatched by our competitors.

No one knows more about insurance in Amherst and Buffalo, New York than our experienced staff. We are ready to consult with you, taking every aspect of your life into consideration. Our goal is to make sure you’re covered for the future.

Paul Wolf Agency, Inc. was established in 2008. We have gone through some major changes in the past few years. We have realized that one company may not best suit the needs of our policyholders. We are proud to announce that we now have the ability to write your insurance through over 10 different personal and commercial lines companies. More choices, competent staff, friendly service, quality products, and extremely competitive pricing are the keys to our success.

We look forward to the opportunity to earn your business.

Sincerely, The staff at Paul Wolf Agency, Inc.

Cutout paper chain family with the protection of cupped hands, concept for security and care

Why did you become an Independent Agent?

We became an independent agency to better service our clients. Our clients now have more choices when it comes to picking an insurance company to do business with. If insurance rates go up, we can now offer them alternatives to rate increases, other companies. We could not make that statement in the past.

How long have you been in the insurance industry?

I have been in the insurance industry for over 13 years.

What is your most memorable experience so far in the insurance industry?

Providing superior coverage, service, and pricing to our policyholders; and watching them leave the office with a smile on their faces knowing they made a good decision and put a few bucks back in their pockets!










Why the Wolf For Your Insurance Needs?

Two standing gray wolves over white background

Customer Service

The Paul Wolf Agency stands alone in customer service. Our agents and staff will provide you with the answers to all you insurance questions.


We provide our customers with our cell phone numbers. If an emergency arises or we are out of the office, contact us on our cell phones 24/7.

Best Coverage, Best Price

With our 30 National Insurance Carriers, we will always find you our best price and coverage. If we don’t beat the price, we will provide you with a small token of our appreciation!

With You Every Step

When a claim situation arises, we are with the customer every step of the way from the start to finish. Call us and we will take care of everything. No need to wait on hold for 30 minutes or speak to a service out of the country. We provide our customers with options and the knowledge to do what’s in the customers’ best interest!

Our Services

What we do

Auto Insurance

We have over 30 auto carriers each with competitive pricing and great coverage for you and your family’s needs.

Life Insurance

Proin a velit aliquam vitae malesuada rutrum. Aenean ullamcorper placerat porttitor velit aliquam vitae.

Homeowners Insurance

We work with over 30 insurance carriers to protect your home or apartment at very affordable pricing. No one beats The Wolf in homeowners.

Commercial Policies

Our agency is growing rapidly in the commercial insurance business. We are adding national carriers to protect you and your business.

Our team

Behind the scenes

Paul Wolf III


Started the agency from scratch in 2005 and the agency continues to grow, learn, and serve the customers who become an extension of the enormous Wolf/Catalano family.

Liza Grimaldi

Sales Manager

Liza is part of the family and has been an integral part of the agency’s growth and success for over 5 years. Liza is dedicated to her work and family, and does a fantastic job at both.

Kayleigh Vara

Office Manager

Kayleigh has been part of the agency for over 3 years now. She is a pleasure to work with and excels at helping each and every customer with their insurance needs.

Jon McKissock


Jon is our lead outside sales professional. Jon also operates a successful restaurant in downtown Buffalo.

Some stats about us

Annual Policies Wrote

Auto Policies

Homeowner Policies

Commercial Policies

Life Insurance Policies

Our best clients

Who love to work with us

kevins logo color

More than 1000 Satisfied Customers

Allstate has been price gouging us for years!  Thank you Paul Wolf Agency and staff for saving us over $800 a year on our insurance!  We can’t thank you enough.

Joe and Kristin Loncar

I saved almost $1,000 a year by switching from Allstate to the Paul Wolf Agency.  I can’t thank you enough, and can’t wait to tell my friends and family about your new agency. Thank you very much.

Faith Nicosia

After shopping around for 2 weeks for Homeowners Insurance, I ran into Paul at the bank and he offered to quote me. He beat the best quote I received by 20% with the same coverage levels!

Dave Mack

Our address

Where you can find us

Office Location

2686 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY

Email Address


Office Hours

Monday – Friday 9am – 5pm

Get in touch!

Send us a message